"Different and moving. "
— Kirkus Reviews

"Mills shines a harsh spotlight on the life of both young elites—expectations, grueling practice regimes, media pressure—and the tough emotional and physical toll it takes. "
— Booklist

"Skating over Thin Ice is a wonderful read which is inspiring and uplifting. There are many allusions to various composers and classical music works which may inspire some readers to open up to classical music, a genre which is perhaps unfamiliar to them. As a reviewer, I need to add a small caveat or confession at this point. I am also a classically trained pianist — though never considered a prodigy! — so Imogen resonates a great deal with me. And like Pere and Papa, I have been known to cheer for my favourite hockey team, so Mills's very capable interweaving of the two worlds seems like a wonderful idea.
Lastly, the title merits some explanation. "When skating over thin ice, our safety is in our speed" is a quote from Ralph Waldo Emerson. The thin ice of the novel seems to refer to the future which is uncertain for both Imogen and Nathan. Readers will cheer them on as they manage to navigate their way to the happiness which is waiting for both of them. Mills has created characters who resonate and who will be remembered long after the covers of the novel have been closed.
Highly Recommended"
— CM Magazine

"In a contemporary setting, Skating Over Thin Ice by Jean Mills gives readers the experience of music from the heart of a child prodigy. Engulfed in music, even perceiving the world around her as if it were a concert hall, Imogene's identity is powerfully constructed around her gift of music. This powerful part of her identity makes it easy for her to withdraw from social interactions. Enter an extremely talented hockey player during Imogene's senior year and the story shares how these young people support each other as they navigate the "coming-of-age" as both gifted and challenged. "
— Worlds of Words magazine, University of Arizona